[ click here for seasonal trophies ]

THE HATTRICK CLUB
Scored in regular-season games unless noted; number in parentheses is number of hattricks
1) Russ Nicolosi (23)
(sixteen times in regular season, four times in consolation games, two playoff games, one pre-season)
2) Bob Brooks (18)
(sixteen regular season, one finals game, one pre-season game)
3) Kevin McLaughlin (17)
(two finals game, one playoff game, twelve regular season, one consolation game, one pre-season)
4) Anthony Toscano (11)
(two playoff games, eight regular season, one pre-season game)
5) Scott LeMatty (11)
(one finals game, nine regular season, one consolation)
6) Jimmy Ferraro (9)
(seven times in regular season, one consolation game, one pre-season game)
 7) Scott Miller (9)
(seven times in regular season, one consolation game, one playoff game)
 8) Brian “TPOC” Newcomb (8)
(seven times in regular season, one pre-season game)
 9) Craig Sudol (6)
10) Marty Maccanico (4)
(one semifinals game, three regular season)
11) Evan Miller (3)
(two regular season, one pre-season game)
12) Jason Serkin (3)
(one finals game)
13) Glenn Farkas (3)
(one pre-season game 4x4)
14) Darren “Gucci” Gugglielmelli (2)
(one pre-season game)
15) Mike Farrell (2)
(one regular season, one pre-season game)
 16) John “Wildman” Cassens (2)
(one finals game)
17) Tim “Ralz” Hand (1)
18) Brian “BB” Kleiman (1)
19) Rob Guimaraes (1)
20) Chris Goione (1)
21) Keith Richardson (1)
22) Rob Armswood (1)
23) Joe Baio (1)
24) Nick Campanale (1)
25) Joe Lyden (1)
26) Rob Trochiano (1)
27) Ken Genalo (1)
28) Joe Nigro (1)
29) David Newcomb (1)
(one consolation game)

MOST GOALS IN A GAME
Number of goals follows player's name
(an asterisk means achieved in playoff game; a double asterisk means pre-season game; a triple asterisk means a consolation game)
1) Jimmy Ferraro (6) 4/21/04 vs. Geriatrics***
 2) Jay Serkin (5) 11/1/07 vs. Team BC
3) Anthony Toscano (5) 9/16/07 vs. Chiefs*
4) Anthony Toscano (5) 2/18/07 vs. Kings
5) Bob Brooks (5) 9/16/07 vs. Chiefs*
6) Bob Brooks (5) 11/12/06 vs. Jaguars
7) Bob Brooks (5) 8/27/06 vs. Kings
8) Russ Nicolosi (5) 5/22/06 vs. Geriatrics
9) Brian Newcomb (5) 5/23/05 vs. NY Times
10) Scott LeMatty (5) 3/7/04 vs. Coyotes
11) Russ Nicolosi (5) 8/17/03 vs. Zombies*
12) Jimmy Ferraro (5) 11/23/03 vs. Micro**
13) Jimmy Ferraro (4) 9/22/02 vs. DireWolves
14) Jimmy Ferraro (4) 3/17/02 vs. RinkRats
15) Scott Miller (4) 6/18/08 vs. Cannibals
16) Scott Miller (4) 4/25/01 vs. Jaguars B
17) Russ Nicolosi (4) 2/7/01 vs. Crunch
18) Russ Nicolosi (4) 5/1/05 vs. Jaguars
19) Rob Armswood (4) 8/16/00 vs. Canadiens
20) Scott LeMatty (4) 5/8/05 vs. DireWolves
21) Anthony Toscano (4) 8/12/07 vs. Phantoms
22) Bob Brooks (4) 10/28/07 vs. Jaguars
23) Scott LeMatty (4) 10/12/08 vs. Cannibals
24) Rob Trochiano (4) 8/2/09 vs. Jaguars
25) Kevin McLaughlin (4) 11/3/10 vs. Hockey Teem

MOST POINTS IN A GAME
Number of points follows player's name
(an asterisk means achieved in playoff game; a double asterisk means a consolation game)
1) Anthony Toscano (7) 2/18/07 vs. Kings
2) Anthony Toscano (7) 8/5/07 vs. Jaguars
3) Anthony Toscano (7) 8/12/07 vs. Phantoms
4) Bob Brooks (7) 11/12/06 vs. Jaguars
5) Bob Brooks (7) 8/27/06 vs. Kings
6) Jimmy Ferraro (7) 4/21/04 vs. Geriatrics**
7) Jimmy Ferraro (7) 3/17/02 vs. RinkRats
8) Scott Miller (6) 10/2/02 vs. Misfits
9) Scott LeMatty (6) 5/08/05 vs. DireWolves
10) Brian Newcomb (6) 5/23/05 vs. NY Times
11) Kevin McLaughlin (6) 1/29/06 vs. Few Good Men
12) Russ Nicolosi (6) 5/22/06 vs. Geriatrics
13) Anthony Toscano (6) 11/12/06 vs. Jaguars
14) Bob Brooks (6) 10/28/07 vs. Jaguars
15) Anthony Toscano (6) 11/4/07 vs. Chiefs
16) Bob Brooks (6) 8/5/07 vs. Jaguars
17) Jay Serkin (6) 11/1/09 vs. Team BC
18) Anthony Toscano (5) 11/30/08 vs. Chiefs
19) Kevin McLaughlin (5) 4/20/08 vs. Jaguars
20) Bob Brooks (5) 1/20/08 vs. Cannibals
21) Bob Brooks (5) 7/15/07 vs. Chiefs
22) Bob Brooks (5) 2/18/07 vs. Kings
23) Anthony Toscano (5) 2/6/07 vs. Ducks
24) Anthony Toscano (5) 11/2/06 vs. Cutters
25) Scott LeMatty (5) 6/11/05 vs. Rink Rats
26) Scott LeMatty (5) 5/23/05 vs. NY Times
 27) Brian Newcomb (5) 7/14/04 vs. Geriatrics
28) Brian Newcomb (5) 1/12/04 vs. Geriatrics
29) Scott LeMatty (5) 11/2/03 vs. Jaguars
30) Russ Nicolosi (5) 8/17/03 vs. Zombies*
31) Mike Farrell (5) 3/19/03 vs. Misfits
32) Chris Goione (5) 9/22/02 vs. DireWolves
33) Russ Nicolosi (5) 12/12/01 vs. Geriatrics
34) Scott Miller (5) 4/25/01 vs. Jaguars B
35) Evan Miller (5) 9/19/01 vs. Phantoms
36) Rob Trochiano (5) 8/2/09 vs. Jaguars
37) Marty Maccanico (5) 8/31/09 vs. Phantoms
38) Russ Nicolosi (5) 10/19/09 vs. Jaguars
39) Marty Maccanico (5) 10/29/09 vs. The Hurt
40) Ken Genalo (5) 12/23/09 vs. Phantoms
41) Anthony Toscano (5) 12/28/09 vs. Jaguars

SCORING LEADERS
Total goals+assists during regular season
1) Bob Brooks (28 pts, 10 goals/18 assists)
(based on eight-game regular season)
2) Anthony Toscano (26 pts, 12 goals/14 assists)
(based on eight-game regular season)
3) Bob Brooks (24 pts, 13 goals/11 assists)
(based on eight-game regular season)
4) Bob Brooks (22 pts, 15 goals/7 assists)
(based on nine-game regular season)
5) Anthony Toscano (22 pts, 12 goals/10 assists)
(based on ten-game regular season)
6) Craig Sudol (21 pts, 13 goals/8 assists)
(based on nine-game regular season)
7) Bob Brooks (20 pts, 15 goals/5 assists)
(based on nine-game regular season)
8) Anthony Toscano (19 pts, 9 goals/10 assists)
(based on nine-game regular season)
9) Bob Brooks (18 pts, 11 goals/7 assists)
(based on ten-game regular season)
10) Darren Gugglielmelli (17 pts, 9 goals/8 assists)
(based on nine-game regular season)
11) Russ Nicolosi (16 pts, 10 goals/6 assists)
(based on seven-game regular season)
12) Jimmy Ferraro (16 pts, 12 goals/4 assists)
(based on eleven-game regular season)
13) Scott LeMatty (15 pts, 11 goals/4 assists)
(based on ten-game regular season)
14) Russ Nicolosi (14 pts, 11 goals/3 assists)
(based on eight-game regular season)
15) Jay Serkin (14 pts, 7 goals/7 assists)
(based on eight-game regular season)
16) Scott LeMatty (13 pts, 7 goals/6 assists)
(based on nine-game regular season)
17) Chris Goione (10 pts, 3 goals/7 assists)
(based on nine-game regular season)

POST-SEASON SCORING
Based on three-game playoff format
1) Russ Nicolosi (9 pts, 6 goals/3 assists)
2) Bob Brooks (7 pts, 3 goals/4 assists)
3) Brian Kleiman (6 pts, 6 goals/0 assists)
4) Craig Sudol (5 pts, 4 goals/1 assist)
Based on two-game playoff format
1) Anthony Toscano (9 pts, 5 goals/4 assists)
2) Bob Brooks (9 pts, 4 goals/5 assists)
3) Bob Brooks (5 pts, 5 goals/0 assists)
4) Dan DiPierro (4 pts, 4 goals/0 assists)
5) John Cassens (4 pts, 3 goals/1 assist)
6) Scott LeMatty (4 pts, 2 goals/2 assists)
7) Glenn Farkas (4 pts, 2 goals/2 assists)

MOST PENALTIES PER GAME
Does not include WTC Benefit Tournament
1) 38:00 minutes 10/8/07 vs. Geriatrics
2) 26:00 minutes 3/30/09 vs. Cannibals
3) 22:00 minutes 7/8/01 vs. Jaguars B
4) 22:00 minutes 10/17/10 vs. Cannibals
5) 21:00 minutes 5/10/06 vs. Tile Cutters
(in Championship game; Pirates lost 4-3)
6) 20:00 minutes 1/13/02 vs. Blackhawks
7) 20:00 minutes 3/24/10 vs. Hocky Teem

MOST PENALTIES PER PERIOD
Does not include game misconducts
1) 22:00 minutes 1st: 10/8/07 vs. Geratircs
2) 16:00 minutes 2nd: 2/27/11 vs. Bulldogs (Semifinals)
3) 16:00 minutes 2nd: 10/8/07 vs. Geratircs
4) 14:00 minutes 1st: 3/30/09 vs. Cannibals
5) 10:00 minutes 2nd: 7/26/06 vs. Team Maxwell
6) 8:00 minutes 1st: 7/8/01 vs. Jaguars B
7) 8:00 minutes 2nd: 7/22/01 vs. Blizzard

MOST PENALTIES PER PERIOD
Total includes both teams' combined minutes
1) 35:00 minutes 1/13/02 vs. Blackhawks

BEST REGULAR-SEASON RECORD
Two points for a win, one point for a tie
1) 16 pts (8-0-0: Wednesday; Summer '08)
(based on eight-game regular season)
2) 24 pts (11-1-2: Wednesday; Summer '04)
(based on fourteen-game regular season)
3) 16 pts (8-1-0: Sunday; Fall '06)
(based on nine-game regular season)
4) 14 pts (7-1-0: Sunday; Summer '08)
(based on eight-game regular season)
 5) 15 pts (7-1-1: Wednesday; Winter '05)
(based on nine-game regular season)
6) 14 pts (7-3: Sunday; Spring '07)
(based on ten-game regular season)
7) 12 pts (6-2-0: Wednesday; Fall '04)
(based on eight-game regular season)
8) 12 pts (6-2-0: Wednesday; Fall '04)
(based on eight-game regular season)
9) 12 pts (6-2-0: Wednesday; Spring '07)
(based on eight-game regular season)
10) 12 pts (6-2-0: Sunday; Summer '07)
(based on eight-game regular season)
11) 12 pts (6-2-0: Sunday; Fall '07)
(based on eight-game regular season)
12) 9 pts (3-1-3: Sunday; Winter '01)
(based on seven-game regular season)

WORST REGULAR-SEASON RECORD
Two points for a win, one point for a tie
1) 0 points (0-8)
Sunday team; Winter '04
(based on eight-game regular season, one forfeit)
1) 1 point (0-6-1)
Wednesday team; Summer '01
(based on seven-game regular season)
2) 4 points (1-3-3)
Sunday team: Winter '01
(editor's note: went on to win Championship!)
(based on seven-game regular season)
3) 4 points (1-6-2)
Wednesday team; Winter '06
(based on nine-game regular season)
4) 7 points (2-6-1)
Sunday team; Summer '04
(editor's note: went on to win Championship!)
(based on nine-game regular season, but wins now count as 3pts each)

MOST TIES IN REGULAR-SEASON
Based on an 8-game season
1) 5 (Wednesday team; Summer '02)

BEST G.A.A.
Goals Against Average
SEASON: 0.85 (6 goals in 7 games)
34th Sunday season
SEASON: 1.25 (10 goals in 8 games)
27th Sunday season
SEASON & PLAYOFFS: 1.50 (12 goals in 8 games)
34th Wednesday season
PLAYOFFS: 0.50 (1 goal in 2 games)
14th Sunday season
PLAYOFFS: 1.50 (3 goals in 2 games)
45th Wednesday season

SHUTOUTS
Stats from post-Eatontown era
1) Harris Siegel (60)
(two shutouts in playoffs, two in finals)
2) Rob Osa (1)
3) Doug Collimore (1)
4) Steve Carr (1)
5) Casey LeCompte (1)
6) Frank Costagliola (1)
7) Corey Sullivan (1)
8) Mike Griffiths (1)

SHOOTOUT RECORD
Shootouts are only used during Playoff games
11-5 (16 shootouts total, 11 wins)
(The Pirates won three times and lost twice in Championship games by a shootout; the Summer 2005 All-Star game was also won by Harris 2-0)

STRANGE BUT TRUE
Interesting tidbits of Pirate lore
Aug. 3, 2005: The only All-Star game ever played at GoodSports featured three Pirate forwards on the Western squad: Chris Goione, Craig Sudol, and Evan Miller. Ironcially, the Eastern Conference goalie took ill and Harris substituted in net — where he faced his own Pirate teammates! To make things more bizarre, the East ended-up winning in a shootout.

Jan. 25, 2006: A game against the Jaguars went into overtime and ended in a 0-0 tie — the only scoreless tie in Pirate history!

Jan. 31, 2007: At the 17:35-mark of the final period vs. the Geriatrics, the Pirates scored their tenth goal to win 10-2 — the fastest “Mercy” in Pirate history.

June 18-19, 2007: During a Semifinals game vs. Jaguars, the Pirates “Mercy” them at the 13:47-mark of the final period — the only recorded “Mercy” in Pirate Playoff history. The following night, the Lumberjacks “Mercy” the Pirates at virtually the same time in their game.

December 19, 2007: The Pirates scored two shorthanded goals (E. Miller & B. Newcomb) on the same powerplay against the Red Stars to take a 2-0 lead. More amazingly, #67 tallied the first one unassisted in :00 seconds during the kill — because the scorekeeper never started the clock.

April 6, 13 & 20, 2008: Defenseman Joe Lyden scores the opening goals in three consecutive Sunday night games. In his fourth attempt (on April 27), the goalie snags his backhander to end his streak. He nets his first Pirate hattrick later that night.

June 29-July 20, 2008: During a span of six Sunday and Wednesday games, the Pirates did not surrender a goal. They outscored opponents 29-0 and logged 224:32-minutes of shutout hockey. The streak included 5 shutouts and 1 forfeit with more than 162:00-minutes (7 periods plus) starting out the Summer Sunday season.

Summer 2008 — Perfection: The Wednesday Pirates were a 8-0 during the regular season and won the Championship, completing an undefeated 10-game run. During the streak, the Pirates compiled three shutouts (one in the Finals) and one “mercy” (in the Semifinals). Ironically the previous Wednesday season the team didn't even make the Playoffs!

July 31, 2013: Ryan Nicolosi, son of the celebrated Captain Russ, scores his first goal as a Pirate. Known as “Coach” for his decade of unfailing attendance behind the bench, the Wall native assumes the spot of Right Wing and nets his debut score in a 3-3 tie. In the tradition of the Howe family, Ryan became one of the first “second generation Pirates” in Franchise history.

RETIRED NUMBERS
Currently only two number have been retired by the Coastal Pirates
#22: Stephen Zack, co-founder of the Coastal Pirates franchise, had his number retired in the Spring of 1997. Steve, or “Little Stevie” as he was fondly known, didn't lead the team in any scoring or plus/minus categories, but he had the distinction of being a “tenacious defensiveman” who had more penalties committed upon himself than any other Pirate ever. In 1998, Zack returned to the ice at Eatontown for a final hurrah, but after he was viciously checked his wife insisted he retire permanently. Since that time, no other Pirate has skated with the legendary “22” on their back.

#28*: Ed “Scooby” Southworth retired following the Summer 2003 season, ending his 9-year run in Pirate black. Scooby was one of the three members of the Stavola Construction team that would become the core of the Coastal Pirates during their inaugural season in 1996. His defensive style has been called “fearless” due to his disregard for his own personal safety while blocking shots, and the fact that he played without benefit of a facemask or shield during his tenure. His effortless coast-to-coast skating abilities and his rowdy locker room antics will be missed. During his nearly decade-long run, Scooby collected 4 Championship rings, 2 Lady Byngs (Sportsmanship), 1 Hart (Season MVP) and 1 Norris (Defense) Trophy, along with 24+ Silver Skulls.
*Scooby made a comeback in 2004 and his number is once-again active.